Chemistry and Values: How to Choose a Coach You'll Actually Work With

Monday, November 16, 2026

The Growth Stage/Business Coaching/Chemistry and Values: How to Choose a Coach You'll Actually Work With

The short answer: choose a coach you feel comfortable with and who shares your values, then confirm that they will also challenge you and have run a real business. Chemistry gets you talking. Fit with your goals, your standards and your appetite for straight feedback is what gets results.

Many owners pick a coach after one pleasant call. That is understandable, because you will spend hours with this person, often talking about money, people and pressure. But a good first impression is only one input. This post gives you a way to test fit before you sign, without turning the choice into a research project.

Why chemistry matters, and why it is not enough

You will not open up to someone you do not trust, and a coach can only work with what you tell them. So rapport is a real requirement. It is also easy to overrate. A coach who is warm, funny and agrees with everything you say will feel great on a first call and may do very little for your business.

The research is mixed on how much the relationship itself drives results. One randomized controlled trial by researchers Erik de Haan, Joanna Molyn and Viktor Nilsson found that how clients rated the coaching relationship predicted effectiveness early on, but did not strongly predict the gains made in later sessions. The authors describe their conclusions as preliminary, because they rest on only two samples. The practical lesson for an owner is modest and useful: do not treat "we clicked" as proof the coaching will work. Treat it as the entry ticket, then test everything else.

The Fit Scorecard: five things to check

Score each item from 1 to 5 after your first call. A coach does not need a perfect score, but a 1 on challenge or competence should end the conversation, however pleasant the call felt.

Fit areaWhat to look forHow to test it on a call
ChemistryYou feel heard and can say what is really going on.Did you say something you would not tell a stranger? Did they listen without rushing to a pitch?
ValuesShared view on honesty, effort, how people are treated and what success means.Ask what they refuse to do for a client. Ask about a time they turned work down.
ChallengeWilling to disagree with you, kindly and with reasons.Share a plan you are unsure about. Do they probe it or praise it?
CompetenceHas built or run real businesses, not just advised on them.Ask for two examples from their own operating experience. See our track record check.
StyleTheir pace, structure and tone suit how you work.Ask how a typical month runs and what you are expected to bring.

Six questions for the first call

  1. "What did the last owner you worked with stop doing because of your advice?" A strong coach can name something concrete.
  2. "What would make you tell me coaching is not right for me?" You want someone who will say no.
  3. "How do you handle it when you disagree with a client?" Listen for specifics, not "I always support my clients."
  4. "Who will I be working with, week to week?" Confirm the person you meet is the person you get.
  5. "How will we know it is working by day 90?" Expect measures tied to revenue, profit or hours, not just feelings.
  6. "What do you need from me?" Good coaching is a two-way commitment, and the answer shows how they think about accountability.

If you want to see what a good first hour feels like, read our first session test.

What owners say about fit

Kevin D'Ambros-Smith has coached since 2017 and has worked with 200+ businesses one-on-one across 30+ industries. These two comments come from New Zealand clients who took part in an Icehouse coaching programme:

Kevin is great to work with. He has strong knowledge, shares relevant examples and stories and is empathic and real. I really enjoy working with him.Heidi Lance
Icehouse coaching programme client (New Zealand)
Kevin is very supportive and really gets our business. He has been amazing to work with.Gemma Adams
Icehouse coaching programme client (New Zealand)

A 90-day trial plan

You can reduce the risk of a poor match by treating the first three months as a structured trial. Agree the plan in writing before you start.

DaysActionOwnerMeasure
1 to 7Score two or three coaches on the Fit Scorecard after one call each. Drop any with a 1 on challenge or competence.OwnerShortlist of one or two, with scores
8 to 30Run the first sessions. Agree the one constraint to fix and the measure that shows it moving.Owner and coachWritten constraint, measure and 90-day target
31 to 60Check the evidence. Are commitments being met, and did the coach challenge at least one of your assumptions?OwnerShare of commitments completed, plus one challenged assumption
61 to 90Hold a fit review. Decide to continue, change the scope or stop. Confirm exit terms in advance.Owner and coachClear decision, with terms that allow you to walk away

Frequently asked questions

Should I choose a coach I like or one who challenges me?

You need both. Comfort lets you be honest, and challenge stops you repeating the same mistakes. If you can only get one, choose challenge from someone you can at least respect and talk to.

How many coaches should I speak to before deciding?

Two or three is usually enough. More than that tends to produce delay, not clarity. Use the same Fit Scorecard and the same six questions with each so you can compare them fairly.

Can I change coaches if the fit is wrong?

Yes, and the contract should make that easy. Before you sign, check the notice period, what happens to fees already paid and whether you can pause or end the arrangement without penalty.

Want to test the fit yourself? Book a free 30-minute call and use the six questions above.

Read about one-on-one coaching or see the programs.

Published 17 November 2026. Testimonials are quoted word for word from the person named. Results are specific to each business and are not typical.

Kevin D'Ambros-Smith Logo Black Font & White Background png
customer1 png

Hi, I Am Kevin D'Ambros-Smith
​The Simple-Growth Coach

​The Simple-Growth Coach

Kevin is a Business Growth Expert and known as 'The Simple-Growth Coach'.
He is a million dollar coach and specializes in empowering ambitious business owners to build remarkable 7 and 8-figure businesses.
Kevin offers a unique perspective, having worked with some of the world’s largest brands he brings 'insider knowledge' from many of the world's most successful corporates.
​​​Kevin has used this knowledge to co-found nine companies, transforming them from start-ups into multi-million-dollar enterprises.

1 png

Work with Kevin

I love business!

And I love helping ambitious business owners build amazing companies that deliver their dream lives.

If you are ready to 'shoot for the moon' and take your business into the stratosphere and beyond - I would love to be your mentor, advisor and guide on this amazing journey. 

If this sounds like you, please click on the link below - I look forward to helping you build the business and life you desire and deserve.

© Kevin D'Ambros-Smith, Simple-Growth and Motherbase Ltd