Too Many Coaches, Too Many Claims: A Simple 5-Step Selection Checklist

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The Growth Stage/Business Coaching/Too Many Coaches, Too Many Claims: A Simple 5-Step Selection Checklist

The short answer: pick a business coach in five steps: write down the problem and the life goal behind it, shortlist three coaches you can verify, run the same 20-minute call with each, compare scope, fees and exit terms side by side, then start with a 90-day trial that has measures. If a coach cannot survive that process, you have saved yourself months and money.

Search for a business coach and you will find hundreds of them, each promising growth. Most owners respond in one of two ways: they pick whoever has the best marketing, or they book a dozen discovery calls and lose weeks of selling time. Neither is a method. This checklist replaces both with a process you can finish in about two weeks, using the same questions for every candidate so the comparison is fair.

Step 1: Name the problem and the life goal behind it

Before you speak to anyone, write two things on one page. First, the real business problem as you see it today: cash flow, a sales plateau, a team that needs you for every decision. Second, the life goal that sits behind the business goal: more income, more time, a sale-ready asset, a holiday with the phone off. A good coach will test your diagnosis and may change it, but you should arrive with a starting point. It also gives you a filter: a coach who pitches a program before asking about either has told you something.

Step 2: Shortlist three coaches you can verify

Three is enough. More just adds calls. For each name, check four things before you book anything:

  • Operator experience: have they built or run a business, and can they say which ones?
  • Relevant stage: do they work with businesses your size, not just start-ups or corporations?
  • Named references: can they connect you with a client who has been through the work? Our guide to choosing a coach you will actually work with covers fit in more depth.
  • Plain pricing: is the fee structure published or explained clearly on a first call?

Drop anyone who fails two of the four. Claims such as "transformed hundreds of businesses" are not evidence unless the coach can describe the work behind them.

Step 3: Run the same 20-minute call with each

Twenty minutes is enough to learn what you need. Use the same five questions every time and take notes in the same grid:

  1. What do you think is the constraint in my business, and what would you check to confirm it?
  2. Which business owners like me have you worked with, and what changed?
  3. Who will actually coach me, and how often will they be in the room?
  4. What does the first 90 days look like, with owners, dates and measures?
  5. What would make you tell me coaching is not the right move right now?

The fifth question is the most useful. A coach who answers it honestly is thinking about your result, not their pipeline.

Step 4: Compare them on one page

Copy this scorecard into a spreadsheet and score each coach from 1 to 5 on every line. Add the totals only after you have scored each line on its own.

CriterionWhat a 5 looks likeWhat a 1 looks like
DiagnosisAsks questions and names a likely constraint before pitching anything.Pitches a program in the first call.
Operator experienceSpecific businesses built or run, with honest detail on mistakes.Vague titles and borrowed case studies.
Fit with your stageExamples from businesses of your size and industry type.One framework for every owner.
Senior attentionThe person you meet is the person who coaches you.Sold by one person, delivered by another.
Scope and feesWritten scope, clear fee, flexible terms, a clean exit.Long lock-in, vague deliverables.
ProofVerbatim client comments and a reference you can call.Unattributed claims and polished testimonials.

If two coaches tie, choose the one whose scope and exit terms you understand best. Our post on keeping momentum between coaching sessions shows what good follow-through looks like once you start.

Step 5: Start with a 90-day trial that has measures

Whoever you choose, agree what success looks like before the first session. A simple 90-day plan keeps both sides honest:

DaysActionOwnerMeasure
1 to 14Agree the constraint, the goal and the three numbers you will track (for example revenue, margin, hours worked).Owner and coachOne-page plan signed off
15 to 45Fix the first constraint. Delegate or drop one task that keeps you in the weeds.OwnerFirst measure moving; one task off your desk
46 to 75Review progress with your numbers, not impressions. Adjust the plan.Owner and coachWritten review, next three actions agreed
76 to 90Decide: continue, change scope or stop.OwnerDecision made against the original measures

What a good result sounds like

Kevin D'Ambros-Smith has coached 200+ businesses one-on-one across 30+ industries since 2017. This comment comes from one of his coaching clients and is quoted exactly as written:

Kevin has been a game changer for us. I had tried a couple of high-profile US entrepreneur programs but found these just talked about 'mindset', whereas Kevin gives practical advice to grow your business that you can implement immediately.Brett
Abeille

Frequently asked questions

How many coaches should I talk to before deciding?

Three is usually enough. Fewer than three gives you nothing to compare, and more than three mostly adds calls without adding information. Use the same questions and the same scorecard each time.

Should I choose the cheapest option?

Price matters, but scope and exit terms matter more. A lower fee with vague deliverables can cost more than a clear fee with a defined 90-day plan. Compare what you get, who delivers it and how you can leave.

How do I know if coaching is working?

Check against the three numbers you agreed on day one. If those are not moving by the review at day 45 to 75, ask your coach what needs to change, and be ready to stop if the answer is not convincing.

Want a second opinion on your shortlist? Book a call and bring your scorecard. Kevin will tell you plainly what he sees, even if it means pointing you elsewhere.

See how coaching works or learn more about Kevin. Kevin is based in Auckland, New Zealand and coaches owners in the USA and New Zealand by video call.

Published 18 November 2026. Testimonials are quoted word for word from the person named. Results are specific to each business and are not typical.

Kevin D'Ambros-Smith Logo Black Font & White Background png
customer1 png

Hi, I Am Kevin D'Ambros-Smith
​The Simple-Growth Coach

​The Simple-Growth Coach

Kevin is a Business Growth Expert and known as 'The Simple-Growth Coach'.
He is a million dollar coach and specializes in empowering ambitious business owners to build remarkable 7 and 8-figure businesses.
Kevin offers a unique perspective, having worked with some of the world’s largest brands he brings 'insider knowledge' from many of the world's most successful corporates.
​​​Kevin has used this knowledge to co-found nine companies, transforming them from start-ups into multi-million-dollar enterprises.

1 png

Work with Kevin

I love business!

And I love helping ambitious business owners build amazing companies that deliver their dream lives.

If you are ready to 'shoot for the moon' and take your business into the stratosphere and beyond - I would love to be your mentor, advisor and guide on this amazing journey. 

If this sounds like you, please click on the link below - I look forward to helping you build the business and life you desire and deserve.

© Kevin D'Ambros-Smith, Simple-Growth and Motherbase Ltd